Mana图形的试用版和加载时间比较（Nintendo Switch与PS4）

47 comments

1. I played the demo on PC(1080ti, Ryzen 3600, SSD) and PS4 Pro in UHD. PC was smoother (that's why I don't think PS4 was 60 FPS), less loading times and it looked better. BUT even on PC there were ugly texture pop-ups. With no graphics settings, I can't tell if you can fix that in the final version. Hope so, because the demo was a lot of fun!

2. Since i dont play portably my choice is simple

3. For 300€ Nintendo includes flash memory that is almost as slow as an HDD… seriously spitting at fans' faces…

4. My plan was to get this on switch as I’ll be playing ff7 on PS4
   This comparison confirms that decision will do me fine 😀

5. The PC version is better.

6. I played the demo on both systems today. I could live with the lower resolution on Switch, but there are frame pacing issues and it looks really jerky sometimes. Textures load slowly too.

7. I'm going to assume that the loading speed is due to the switch using flash memory vs the PS4 HD. Though I am not all that familiar with PS4

8. What about the PS4 pro, which is what I have? Is there a difference?

9. Improved visuals vs improved load times…
   I prefer improved load times!

10. Switch version is best version cause it's also portable

11. What made the original game fun was playing with a Second person. Why is this Remake only 1 player??? Unless they plan on Adding that later…

12. Both versions are perfect for what they are meant for ????

13. This is exactly what I would have wanted from a Secret of Mana remake…

14. Im honestly more hyped for this then the FF7R!

15. not a fan of the "enhanced" shadows on the PS4. It gives the game an unnecessary darker look. 3:42 now that just looks horrible on ps4. Those bricks do not need black lines like that.

16. As much as I would love to have this on my PS4, I need it on my Switch lite, because it's collecting dust and this is the game to justify it's purchase. (Then I'll get it on my PlayStation once there's a price drop)

17. The PS4 port is a joke. Those are very long loading times! People won't care about a little more resolution

18. 10:06 Trials of mana 3 has Minecraft looking ass town ?

19. I guess my primary question would be this: which version, if either, would have the entire game on the media?

20. I wonder if the framerate is something they could fix with updates later on?

21. PS4 for me, but maybe Switch version later on. Both look pretty good

22. Well this test doesn't mean much if you don't give us some background information. Was this game installed on the internal hard drive or an external one (load times can vary greatly b/w the two) and was it running off a disc or digital only? Was the switch in portable or docked mode? Was it running off a downloaded copy or a cartridge? You need to provide data like this if you're going to post videos that are suppose to analyze this stuff, otherwise its kinda meaningless.

23. Interesting how the Switch version is the one with the bloom overlay this time. It can also be patched to use a higher clock rate for loading, but that's up to Squenix. By the end of the demo, I wanted to play more.

24. So….. wait, and get it cheap when PS5 is out for the best graphics, and no load times. If you said Switch or PS4, you're wrong!

25. Can barely notice the quality of both graphics. At the end, its all about the playbility.

26. So excited for this game. Played the original on Switch, so I'm gonna probably get the PC version.
    Holy cow that dub hurts my soul.

27. MULTIPLAYER FOR THE LOVE OF CHRIST

28. The difference is big if you play on a ps4pro and good 4ktv switch vers has some other technical issues.

29. Going for the PS4 version as always! Don’t use handheld on the switch, can’t stand it! Always hated handheld gaming.

30. Boy, the writing is… not good >_>

31. PS5 version will have zero load times

32. Wonder if ps4 is playing from disc or installed from hd, cartridge from switch has faster loading times as expected.

33. Switch faster load times
    Ps4 higher resolution

34. What about the Playstation 2 comparison?

35. The remake looks great ?

36. Man, BIG difference between the 2. The PS4 version has a higher native resolution and looks MUCH better, and runs at 60FPS vs 30FPS for the Switch. Thats a no brainer for me, Switch doesnt even come close.

37. Ps4

38. Thought about getting it on PS4, but the rumored censorship on PS4 concerns me. The load times are much better on Switch so getting it there.

39. After having played the demo on Switch I can safely say that graphics don't really matters in a game like this one. I mean the characters looks great but the environements are a bit lacking. Really nice atmosphere but a bit empty at time. So a graphic downgrade won't even be that noticeable. Even if it feels much much better to play at 60FPS. I will go for the Switch version, but PS4 version looks great.

40. 30 fps vs 60 fps, well for the switch it's awesome tho, and I prefer get them both, with pc version ofcourse

41. Switch version is ugly, clunky and blurry. PS4 version is just ugly… These are some low-effort graphics. It's like they tried to make something that looks good but gave up halfway… It doesn't come close to the graphical quality of Dragon Quest.

42. Can you test load speeds on PS4 pro

43. The Switch version is a huge improvement over what I played at PAX last year. I swear, the Switch version they had playable last September had me very concerned, it was extremely muddy looking and was probably running sub 720p docked. Having played an hour of the demo last night it is looking very good.

44. My opinion: if you want to play it on the tv buy the ps4 version, if you want to play it in portable mode buy the switch version.

45. The blurriness on the switch version is noticeable on my tiny smartphone. Can't imagine how apparent it will be on a big monitor

46. not so much difference beside frame rate, i'm getting Switch version.

47. I feel like it's a win win situation. Just buy the damn game. lol

Comments are closed.